 |
 The Voracious Resurgence |
 
| |
| Prime Weapons • Ultimate Weapons • Ultimate Augments • Abjurations iL119 • JSE Necks • Divergence Augments • Escutcheons | |
| Reforged Armor Artifact: +1 • iL109 • iL119/+2/+3 Relic: +1/+2 • iL109 • iL119/+2/+3 Empyrean: +1/+2 • iL109 • iL119/+2/+3 |
Guides • Crafting • Trusts • Apex Monsters |
Talk:The Truth Lies Hid: Difference between revisions
From FFXI Wiki
m (scenario D) |
mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 27: | Line 27: | ||
| Rakke is honest |
| Rakke is honest |
||
| Rokke |
| Rokke |
||
|- style="background: # |
|- style="background: #d2d2d2;" |
||
| D |
| D |
||
| Rokke is lying |
| Rokke is lying |
||
Revision as of 16:48, 3 July 2020
Sleuthing Game
| Sleuthing Game Summary | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scenario | Rikke (NW) | Rakke (SW) | Rokke (SE) | Answer |
| A | Rikke is honest | Rikke is lying | Rikke is honest | Rakke |
| B | Rokke is lying | Rokke is honest | Rikke is lying | Rikke |
| C | Rokke is lying | Rikke is honest | Rakke is honest | Rokke |
| D | Rokke is lying | Rikke is honest | Rokke is honest | Rokke |
Presumption: Only one Imp is telling the truth. The rest are liars.
Goal: Find contradictions to determine the lying Imps.
Scenario A
- Pair either honest Imp with the lying Imp and presume they are both liars
- Then the second honest Imp would contradict the first because they make the same assertion
- Therefore, only the lying Imp is telling the truth
Scenario B
- Either the first or second is lying: an Imp cannot be both honest and dishonest
- Therefore, the third Imp is a liar by virtue of the presumption
- Negate the third Imp's statement to determine which of the first two Imps is honest
Scenario C
- If Rokke/Rikke were both liars, than Rakke's statement would contradict this by noting Rikke is honest. Therefore, Rakke is lying
- If Rikke was telling the truth, then Rokke's statement is false ⇒ Rakke is honest ⇒ a contradiction
- If Rokke was telling the truth, then Rikke's statement is false ⇒ Rokke is honest + Rakke is a liar; this is a possibility
Scenario D
- Similar to Scenario B
- Rikke would mention "What? My buddy up west tell you same thing? Oh, don't trust him, no no no." and "You trust Rokke, yes? Rokke no lie to no one."
- Presumed it means Rokke is honest rather than Rikkie is lying
- Got this scenario wrong so it needs verification
Glitch
- If you get Scenario C, it is possible to trade your Elixir to the other Imp's even after receiving the correct CS.
- Doing so will negate your progress and you must wait until next game day to reset.
